Corona Crisis - Effects of social and economic scenarios on the legal market - Venturis Consulting Group

Corona Crisis – Effects of social and economic scenarios on the legal market

Apr 09, 2020 venturis News 0 comments

In response to the lockdown, many law firms have now switched to a different way of working. For us, the next sensible steps are to

  • Analyse the Corona crisis in various contexts regarding its potential for development and its impact on the legal market.
  • Identify aspects worth observing that will give us an indication of the changes to be expected.
  • Define areas of action for law firms regarding:
    -Positioning & Strategy
    -Office organization

1. Interdependence between measures of physical distancing and economy

1.1 Lifting the lockdown – resumption of the economy

It is foreseeable that over the coming months we will experience an interplay of withdrawal and temporary reintroduction of restrictive measures / physical distancing depending on the number of infection cases and the spread of the infection.[1] This will continue to strongly influence the economy and its recovery after the current lockdown. This phase of interplay might also last until the end of this year, depending on how quickly treatment options and vaccinations become available.

[1] Tomas Pueyo, Coronavirus: The Hammer and the Dance, March 2020 –

1.2 Indicators are the recovery of the economy

In order to be able to assess the further course of the pandemic and the likelihood that restrictive measures will be relaxed or re-imposed, we feel that the following aspects are worth observing:

  • Trends in case counts and deaths
  • Readiness of hospitals to treat patients
  • Socially accepted catalogue of measures to regulate public life / the economy
  • Progress in the development of therapeutic options and vaccines

2. Recession – possible scenarios

The fact that we are going into a recession is pretty much undisputed among economists. Richard Baldwin, Professor of International Economics at the HEI in Geneva and consultant to the EU and OECD, presents the economic causes, risks and consequences of the crisis from a systemic perspective[2]:

[2] Pennemann, FAZ, Why the crisis is hitting the German economy so hard, online edition 26.03.2020 –

2.1 McKinsey: Delayed recovery vs. longer contraction

In their study ‘COVID-19: Implications for business’[3], published in mid-March, McKinsey describes two rough scenarios, which are further explained in ‘COVID-19: Briefing Materials’[4] (last update 25 March).

[3] McKinsey & Company, COVID-19 – Implications for Business, März 2020 –

[4] McKinsey & Company, COVID-19 – Briefing Materials, March 2020 –

2.1.1 Scenario 1 – Delayed recovery

In this rather positive scenario, it is assumed that the virus is under control by Q2/20. McKinsey expects a recovery at pre-crisis level in China in Q4/20, in the US in Q3/20 and in the Euro zone only in Q1/21.[5]

[5] McKinsey & Company, March 2020, ibid.

2.1.2 Scenario 2 – Longer contraction

In this scenario, it takes longer for the number of new infections to decline. Correspondingly, various government imposed protective measures are in place for a longer period – with the result that a self-reinforcing downward spiral is set in motion. Global GDP in 2020 falls significantly and pre-crisis status is reached in China in Q2/21, in the US in Q1/23 and in the eurozone in Q3/23.[6]

2.2 Economic indicators worth observing

The following indicators seem significant considering the scenarios and possible shocks:

  • Consumer spending on long-term goods and changes in consumption habits (short-term goods, restaurant visits, etc.)
  • Development of worldwide freight traffic and mobility (air travel, holidays, etc.)
  • Investment behaviour of companies
  • Insolvencies and loan defaults
  • Purchase index
  • Unemployment figures

[6] McKinsey & Company, ibid.

3. Future scenarios – Leapfrogging the future

As published on April 1 on Law Com,[7] several law firms are considering reducing partner and associate salaries. This is a sensible measure aimed at economic stability.

However, we believe that now is the time to look beyond stabilisation measures and far ahead. This view is by nature strongly hypothetical. It can, at the same time, serve to structure current developments and open new spaces for thinking.

Read also: Corona Crisis -Areas of actions against social and economic scenarios

Against the background of Corona, the Zukunftsinstitut with headquarters in Frankfurt and Vienna has developed a white paper with four scenarios[8]:

[7] Patel, Dentons Board Mulls Pay Cut For Europe Lawyers, 01.04.20 –

[8] Future Institute, The Corona Effect. Four Future Scenarios, March 2020

We consider these and other scenarios worth reading (cf. link below) in order to assess relevant developments for the economy, clients and the legal market and to draw conclusions for your own organisation, its processes, products and services.

The Zukunftsinstitut has transferred these four scenarios into its Trend-Canvas – a structured method for developing a picture of the future for companies – and thus enables a very stimulating discussion on the future of your own firm.[9]

We do not identify concrete indicators worth observing here but identify and plausibilise the following areas of action.

[9]  Zukunftsinstitut, Trend Canvas Covid-19 Impact Analysis, March 2020 –

Against this background we derived some first thoughts on the relevant areas of actions for law firms in order to cope with the crisis and exit stronger than before.